Post by Amanda Kimmel on May 24, 2012 23:45:30 GMT -5
Also, I'm going to post this, my analysis + rankings:
Yikes.
I personally hate this product, which makes judging even harder. And these five have all done extremely well. It's a tough call here.
Now, for FCO, I'm going to pick the one I think best fits CoverGirl, this product, and would stack up with those of the other winners. In my eyes, that's... Kirsten, actually.
For second, I'm going to pick the photo I like the most after that, all things considered, including theme, modelesquity, pose, all that stuff. That's Monica.
For third, I' will be picking the one that sells the product the best out of the remainder, whether or not it is best suited for CoverGirl. Surprisingly, that's Eliza.
I will rank Kate above Dita.
I am aware that by doing this, I'm basically handing Kirsten the win, but this competition is about PHOTOS. Kate's hardly sells the product and Dita's just doesn't do much for me at all. I blame it all on the chosen product and that Eliza just happened to have a great shoot for it... while Kate and Dita didn't.
Unfortunately, in a game like this, that's just how the cookie crumbles. :/
+5 Kirsten
+4 Monica
+3 Eliza
+2 Kate
+1 Dita
I hope that gives insight into what I was thinking while judging.
I personally hate this product, which makes judging even harder. And these five have all done extremely well. It's a tough call here.
Now, for FCO, I'm going to pick the one I think best fits CoverGirl, this product, and would stack up with those of the other winners. In my eyes, that's... Kirsten, actually.
For second, I'm going to pick the photo I like the most after that, all things considered, including theme, modelesquity, pose, all that stuff. That's Monica.
For third, I' will be picking the one that sells the product the best out of the remainder, whether or not it is best suited for CoverGirl. Surprisingly, that's Eliza.
I will rank Kate above Dita.
I am aware that by doing this, I'm basically handing Kirsten the win, but this competition is about PHOTOS. Kate's hardly sells the product and Dita's just doesn't do much for me at all. I blame it all on the chosen product and that Eliza just happened to have a great shoot for it... while Kate and Dita didn't.
Unfortunately, in a game like this, that's just how the cookie crumbles. :/
+5 Kirsten
+4 Monica
+3 Eliza
+2 Kate
+1 Dita
I hope that gives insight into what I was thinking while judging.
